City of Edinburgh

South Gyle (former RBS HQ)

ShelbornShelborn Drummond
Refused / appeal6 sources212 MWLarge
Where it stands6 independent sources
  1. Announced
  2. Proposal notice
  3. Application
  4. Decision
  5. Appeal

Refused by the council. The developer's appeal is with a Scottish Government reporter, who has asked for an environmental assessment first.

Have your say · council applicationRefused. Further comments go to the appeal reporter through the DPEA case page.DPEA appeal case ↗Council record 25/04239/PPP ↗How to have your say
Size212 MWLarge5.3% of Scotland's winter peak demandSite about 6 ha
Surroundings
  • Nearest building 19 m · 423 within 500 m
  • 5% of the site in a surface water flood zone
  • Ancient woodland 825 m away
See the map
Public response1 against · 1 forOn 25/04239/PPP
How the flags work

Red: nearest building within 100 m, 10% or more of the site in a flood zone, or a designation overlapping the site. Amber: building within 500 m, any flood-zone overlap, or a designation within 500 m. Green: none of these. Measured from the council's application site; buildings from OpenStreetMap, flood zones from SEPA, designations from NatureScot and Historic Environment Scotland.

Overview

Councillors refused it unanimously against officers' advice, finding it was not a green data centre under NPF4. On appeal, the reporter ruled an EIA is needed before the appeal can proceed.

Sources disagree: Capacity is 212.42MW in APRS and 213MW in the press.

The developer's case

We have not found a project website or public statement from the developer beyond what is listed below.

Shelborn website ↗

Jobs in context

Permanent jobs claimedNone published
At the 1.6 per MW study averageabout 339for 212 MW
Industry modeltechUK, based on older, smaller sites8.5
Planned UK sitesVerdant study of 20 schemes, 20261.6
QTS Cambois, Northumberland720 MW, about 400 jobs0.56

Permanent jobs per megawatt of capacity.

Construction jobs are real but temporary. Figures for "job-years", "jobs supported" or "indirect" jobs count work elsewhere in the economy, not people on site. The per-MW measure comes from the think tank Verdant; techUK says it misses jobs supported outside the site, and the UK Government calls it misleading. The Next Web Resultsense

Site and design

LandFormer RBS headquarters Data Centre Review
Backup powerDiesel generators (objectors' concern) Cockburn Association

Items marked Claim are the developer's own figures, not independently checked.

The objectors' case

Objectors, including the Cockburn Association, raised the diesel backup generators and whether the scheme met the national definition of a green data centre. The council refused it. Cockburn Association

formal objections1

The opening lines summarise in our own words how objectors present their case. Campaign claims get the same checks as the developer's figures. Petition signatures are not verified as local and are not formal objections to the council.

Site and surroundings

Loading map layers…
Site centreResidentialIndustrial / commercialWoodland River floodSurface water floodCoastal flood SSSI / SAC / SPAAncient woodlandHeritage designation Listed buildingSchool, care or healthPower line250 m · 500 m · 1 km from the site centre

See the exact red-line boundary on the council's map ↗ · Building counts and flood shares are measured from the council's application boundary; the rings are drawn from the site centre. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors, available under the Open Database Licence. Flood maps © SEPA; designations © NatureScot and © Historic Environment Scotland; all under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Contains OS data © Crown copyright and database right 2026.

Planning

Where it stands: Refused 9 Feb 2026 · appeal PPA-230-2794.

  1. Proposal of application notice25/01968/PAN · Pre-application Consultation approved. · 02 May 2025
  2. EIA screening or scoping25/03575/SCR · EIA Not Required · 30 Jul 2025
  3. Planning application lodged25/04239/PPP · Refused · 09 Feb 2026
  4. Council decisionRefused
  5. Appeal to Scottish MinistersIn progress
Site locationCentre of the application site for 25/04239/PPP, about 6 ha. Grid reference E 318350 N 671811.
See the red-line boundary on City of Edinburgh Council's map ↗
Council planning record · City of Edinburgh Council
ReferenceTypeStatusDateApplicant
25/04239/PPPPlanning permission in principleRefused09 Feb 2026Shelborn Drummond Ltd
25/01968/PANProposal of application noticePre-application Consultation approved.02 May 2025Shelborn Drummond Ltd
25/03575/SCREIA screeningEIA Not Required30 Jul 2025Shelborn Drummond Ltd

Rules that apply

  • Over 50MW, the council must notify Scottish Ministers within seven days of validating an application (in force since 17 Aug 2026). Scottish Government
  • Over 50MW, an Environmental Impact Assessment is now mandatory (Direction of 16 Sep 2026), including for applications already in the system. Scottish Government
  • On 16 Sep 2026 MSPs backed pausing planning decisions on large data centres for up to 12 months while national guidance is drafted, expected by December 2026. Resultsense

Search the City of Edinburgh planning portal for the latest documents, consultee responses and public comments.

Public response

1against
1in support
1neutral
61neighbours notified

50% of comments that took a side were against. From the public comments tab of 25/04239/PPP, read 19 Oct 2026. This council publishes the counts but not the comment text, so what people wrote cannot be analysed.

Concerns reported

Case made for it

Issues as reported in news and campaign coverage, not a count of comments.

Statutory consultees

14 consulted, 11 responded. Including: Policy · Planning Specialists · Corstorphine Gyle

Sources